planetf1.com

Well remember that wing he couldn't get to work at spa.

Do you think the team didn't use Jens info to get it to work in Monza?

_________________
Disclaimer: The above post maybe tongue in cheek.

"I thought I'd get your theories, mock them, then embrace my own. The usual."

Its rare for teammates to use the exact same setup, because they all have little preferences. Copying a setup entirely is usually a last straw problem solving tactic. So I doubt Lewis drove a 100% JB car this year. Data from both cars is always used to develop and maximize parts, so they're always using something that can be attributed to the other guy.

_________________

No. Because they had a Monza specific package at Monza, wich needs a complete different set up compared to Spa.
Spa set up from JB would be useless, for Lewis at Monza.

_________________
"Everything you can imagine is real." Pablo Picasso

Really.

'Cause guess what package Lewis ran at Monza?

The same one Jens used at Spa.

_________________
Disclaimer: The above post maybe tongue in cheek.

"I thought I'd get your theories, mock them, then embrace my own. The usual."

I very much doubt it would be exactly the same as the circuits are different

_________________
PFI Pick 10 Competition

Current Standing: 16th

I don't know why I just spent 5 minutes studying photos when this is available

http://somersf1.blogspot.com/2012/09/mc ... monza.html

_________________

They used the same rear wing but would the set ups be exactly the same for both circuits?

_________________
PFI Pick 10 Competition

Current Standing: 16th

Then why would they have looked at Lewis' Previous data for Jens?

The Circuits are different .


and I never said they would have used the 100% same set up. Just that they likely used JBs Data from Spa. Think logically. would you go into FP1 or work on the Sim with a clean sheet of paper and start from scratch re-learning what has already been learnt. Or would you start with a proven working set up and tune it to suit?

Which one do you think would be a better more efficient use of time and resources? Especially considering both are Low Downforce high speed circuits.

If you were in charge what would you do?

_________________
Disclaimer: The above post maybe tongue in cheek.

"I thought I'd get your theories, mock them, then embrace my own. The usual."

Because even Lewis cannot find the right setup all the time.

Edit

Or get a bit lost with setup.

_________________
Lewis is to Twitter what Grosjean is to first corners.

The lack of in-season testing increases the dependency of both sides of the garage on data acquired at previous race meetings - if you have a log of the behavior change of one element of the car through different configurations you use it, regardless of which driver was behind the wheel when it was gathered. Further, the engineers would know things like customary differences in performance from driver to driver, and circuit to circuit. Think of how the teams work year to year. When its time to start developing an upgrade for any circuit, or to begin working on a weekend package via simulations, they look at data from both cars acquired in years past as a starting point...and sometimes one or both of their current cars are driven by someone who was with another team in those prior years.

_________________

I believe when looking at Hamilton's data it was more to do with his driving style and how he was using the tyres rather than the set up itself

_________________
PFI Pick 10 Competition

Current Standing: 16th

Well isn't that using info the same way.

In one hand Lewis worked out how to drive the tyres in the other Jens side worked out how to use the wing.

After all it's a team sport. So where's the problem?

_________________
Disclaimer: The above post maybe tongue in cheek.

"I thought I'd get your theories, mock them, then embrace my own. The usual."

The problem is that Jenson has passed off his May to July lapse as "helping the team in a way"
and blamed the loss of constructors title on "the cars' " lack of pace , which is clearly not the case ,


Funny thing is Lewis wanted to use the in season testing as an opportunity to get a better-understanding of the tyres , he clearly realised they could pose a major problem . McLaren blocked him much to his irritation ,the other teams allowed their drivers to test , Jenson didn't think it was necessary for them to go and it turns out that he needed it more than Lewis .

Nope, that is called telemtry

Good article here explaining how and why telemetry and data used when one driver is struggling .

http://scarbsf1.com/blog1/2011/08/18/te ... roduction/

the title should be: Buttons lack of pace cost us the title.

_________________

Nice! First bash of the year, well done

_________________
Lewis is to Twitter what Grosjean is to first corners.

It's guesswork what you do here, we know JB used Lewis data & copied his set up to come out of his problems, but you have nothing to prove Lewis copied Jensons.
It's not that Hamilton was lost on set up like Button was, he had just no time at Spa to work a working set up out, at Monza he had 62 laps for it.

_________________
"Everything you can imagine is real." Pablo Picasso

Had he used JBs info? How do you know it?

_________________
"Everything you can imagine is real." Pablo Picasso

Well if you watched the JB interview on sky you would know that Lewis used JB's setup in Europe ( Race setup that is )

_________________
Lewis is to Twitter what Grosjean is to first corners.

But it's a bit rich to say "pretty sure Lewis used Jensons set up at least one this year"
because there is no proof & nobody here knows it!
On the other side we have the confirmation Button used & copied Hamiltons set up & data.
The discussion started because someone here wrote about JB:

wich was ridiculous, to say.

_________________
"Everything you can imagine is real." Pablo Picasso

Link

_________________
"Everything you can imagine is real." Pablo Picasso

But the one I quoted was that Lewis never used JB's setup ( Which is hogswash )

_________________
Lewis is to Twitter what Grosjean is to first corners.

It was on a Sky interview with JB did I not make that clear?

_________________
Lewis is to Twitter what Grosjean is to first corners.

You can say anything, without a link or a quote...

_________________
"Everything you can imagine is real." Pablo Picasso

Where was this quote, I must have missed it

_________________
"Everything you can imagine is real." Pablo Picasso

After all it's a team sport. So where's the problem?[/quote]
Had he used JBs info? How do you know it?[/quote]
Well if you watched the JB interview on sky you would know that Lewis used JB's setup in Europe ( Race setup that is )[/quote]
Link[/quote]
It was on a Sky interview with JB did I not make that clear?[/quote]
You can say anything, without a link or a quote...[/quote]
like I said it was on Sky if you don't subscribe you won't get it ( I will look on YouTube in the morning)

_________________
Lewis is to Twitter what Grosjean is to first corners.

Had he used JBs info? How do you know it?[/quote]
Well if you watched the JB interview on sky you would know that Lewis used JB's setup in Europe ( Race setup that is )[/quote]
Link[/quote]
It was on a Sky interview with JB did I not make that clear?[/quote]
You can say anything, without a link or a quote...[/quote]
like I said it was on Sky if you don't subscribe you won't get it ( I will look on YouTube in the morning)[/quote]
Very nice

_________________
"Everything you can imagine is real." Pablo Picasso

Well if you watched the JB interview on sky you would know that Lewis used JB's setup in Europe ( Race setup that is )[/quote]
Link[/quote]
It was on a Sky interview with JB did I not make that clear?[/quote]
You can say anything, without a link or a quote...[/quote]
like I said it was on Sky if you don't subscribe you won't get it ( I will look on YouTube in the morning)[/quote]
Very nice[/quote]
Great so I'm lying then!!!

_________________
Lewis is to Twitter what Grosjean is to first corners.

I don't....what are....huh?

_________________

It's very nice from you to look for the quote ( video), this is what I meant with "very nice"

_________________
"Everything you can imagine is real." Pablo Picasso

Ok cool, check out YouTube ( Jenson Button interview on Sky in full about 4 min in ) I would link but on phone don't know how

_________________
Lewis is to Twitter what Grosjean is to first corners.

If by Europe you mean Valencia


http://blogs.bettor.com/Jenson-Button-t ... ws-a164504

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/motors ... track.html

Yes i do mean Valencia, Jenson went into the weekend using Lewis' ( BASE ) setup and adjusted it over the weekend to get the car to his liking.
Lewis for what ever reason couldn't find sweet spot and went towards JB's race setup.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mR8uz6EH15o

_________________
Lewis is to Twitter what Grosjean is to first corners.

Did people not watch F1 last year?

Well i'm not sure how much the drivers use one another's setup data and obviously in Spa Hamilton got it totally wrong but i guess this can happen from time to time. But this is much different to the problems Button was having, his driving style was preventing him from getting the performance out of the car that Hamilton was, plus he couldn't adapt his driving which Hamilton had done, the team basically had to make the car work for him which took several races to sort out.

_________________
PFI Pick 10 Competition

Current Standing: 16th

I miss your point

_________________
PFI Pick 10 Competition

Current Standing: 16th

Big claims for someone looking in from the outside.

_________________

Thats because the tyres were not behaving as tyres traditional behaved. The boffins were baffled. In Canada due to the mess up on Friday regarding JBs gear box they put JB out on the Montreal specific rear suspension (More Squat I believe) and Hammys set up because obviously Hammy had meaningful running time. (It was originally planned JB would use the standard rear suspension minus some "Gizmo" they had been using) .

How ever as we seen the tyre wear difference between the two was extreme.

Now if you were a team boss and two of your drivers were showing total different tyre wear patterns on the same set up, what would you do?

a) Ignore it and carry on?

b ) Analyse the data to cure the problem and understand the tyres better?

Remember understanding the tyres better doesn't just help one driver.

Or another way of looking at it. In Brazil between the two cars McLaren ran something like 32 different downforce levels when testing the new tyres. Should all the settings tested on Hammys car and info garnered be binned so that it doesn't help Sergio and JB?

Schui and Rosberg also tested the new tyres. Should Merc keep all they discovered secret from Hammy . Do you think any data that was gained by schui or Rosberg when testing 2013 parts shouldn't be used to help Hammy?

Of course not that would be daft and a waste of time shooting themselves in the foot. They are teams, it's a team sport and the teams own the info. They will analyse whatever they can to improve the car regardless of who the driver was and if the analyses is correct then that helps the team improve the car which helps both drivers. The only reason such a big deal was made of the whole thing was because it was during the pissing contest whilst contract negotiations were going on. I would bet money on it, if Lewis had signed before this then it wouldn't have been mentioned.

_________________
Disclaimer: The above post maybe tongue in cheek.

"I thought I'd get your theories, mock them, then embrace my own. The usual."

This what is so confusing to me, despite different driving styles Hamilton can basically jump into Button's car and drive it, but Hamilton's driving style is so alien to him he's not able to do likewise.

_________________
PFI Pick 10 Competition

Current Standing: 16th