planetf1.com

after watching some of bruno's q2 qualifying laps I notticed that he was just too smooth, leaving a lot time on the table, especially after watching the onboard in the last sector in abu dhabi, he was just not carrying enough speed, and not attacking the curbs as hard as he should, the car looked very well balanced, I dont know if it was just a lack of confidence or what, he was always qualifying around 14th, I dont know what he would have lost if he just tried to be more agressive in attacking the curbs. what do you guys think?, I really think he is a lot better than the performance he showed, shame he didnt get the brawn drive in 2009, as I think he would have given button a run for his money because the tyres were easier to warm up as that has been his problem with the williams car.

_________________
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LrfWRW1MJhQ

His driving styles just didn't suit the pirrellis so he needed set up spot on to compensate and if you are having 1.5hrs less than most others on track you will suffer simple. He proved in lower formula and Renault he can be fast in quali.

Completely agree with both of you.

Maybe he's nothing special, but I don't feel like we've seen his best. I can't think of anyone who was so good in the wet at GP2 level without turning into something worthwhile at F1 level. He had a very compromised path to F1 that left him behind his contempories on the learning curve. I think there's an argument to be made for him possibly having more untapped potential than others of his generation because of that.

_________________
Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able? Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing? Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing? Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing? Then why call him God?
-Epicurus

Totally agree. Most people who seem to slate Bruno unnecessarily just seem to mention Ayrton, say something generic about "ruining the family name" and don't say much more.

I'd like him to take the second seat at Caterham and push the team forward, Heikki style.

... and don't forget that he usually beat Maldonado when both finished the race.

Is there any news regarding Senna's presence in F1 for this year?

_________________
"I'm going to go in the car but I'm telling you, from today, I'm going to do what I want to do when it's wet."-- Prost, 1982, immediately after Didier's accident.

He needs to be a lot more aggressive over one lap. If he could heat the tyres up properly on his out lap he'd probably have found himself much higher up the grid.

_________________
1994 1995 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 Get well soon Schumi.

No one call anyone a moo-pickle...

in the force India seat thread, just that he hsnt been ruled out yet and he still wants a competitive seat as possible, have to wait and see i guess

His qualifying was downright embarrassing at some points in the season. This was especially so at Barcelona when Maldonado secured a front-row place and Bruno spun off clumsily into the gravel. There were a number of qualifying sessions wherein Maldonado showed his superiority:

Abu Dhabi: Maldonado 4th, Senna 15th
Brazil: Maldonado 6th, Senna 12th
Belgium: Maldonado 3rd, Senna 17th
Britain: Maldonado 7th, Senna 15th
Valencia: Maldonado 3rd, Senna 14th

The argument that Senna's end results were on-par with Maldonado's is valid, but is perhaps only used to hold on to the hope that Bruno could remain in the sport. Williams needs star drivers at the moment and Senna hasn't shown himself to be one. Valtteri Bottas may prove himself to be unimpressive in the months to come and that may open the door for a Senna return, though the Brazilian isn't a youngster anymore and a return to the sport at 30 years old won't be easy for him, nor will it be an attractive prospect for a Formula One team.

Button has shown himself to be a match for Hamilton and I can't see a first-year Senna having been able to challenge Jenson for the title. Honda offered Alonso a drive in 2008, though. Now that would've been fun to see.

_________________

Bruno was only 2 tenth slower than Button in the 2009 Brawn test, but Brawn decided to choose Barrichello for his immense experience.
His smooth style doesn't fit very well with Pirelli tyres in the single lap, but it works well in race conditions (where he outpaced Maldonado many times despite losing FP1).

Look at him in China (finished 7th), so smooth:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VXBdvN1DMnw

Next year's tyres will be easier to put in the right temperature window, so i see a faster Senna in qualify too.
Only hope that someone will give him another opportunity.

But since when has testing been a test of out-and-out driver ability? If Brawn (Though was it not a test carried out when the team was still Honda?) had thought that Bruno was the next big thing, you'd have thought they would have signed him. After all, the team didn't know if they were going to survive into 2010 - what good was an experienced driver over one that might blitz the field in '09?



That's an excuse, but it doesn't completely defend Bruno. If he was a top driver, you'd have expected him to have worked around that before the end of a 20-race season. It's not as if it was a problem that was inherent within the FW34 as his team-mate had no such issues.



Unfortunately for Bruno, being smooth with the wheel doesn't necessarily result in a fast lap time. It may have helped his tyre conservation, and perhaps that is why his race results were closer to Maldonado's, but Button - widely regarded as the 'smoothest' driver in recent years - didn't suffer like Bruno in qualifying.



Unfortunately it looks as if we may never know.

_________________

the quali gap between JEV and RIC is very similar to the gap between senna and maldonado, the difference is that vergne starts very near his team mate even if he was way slower, whereas senna starts 15th and maldonado makes it to q3.

_________________
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LrfWRW1MJhQ

He also took so strange lines when ever I saw him onboard.

He also simply cracked under the pressure, even his best Q was some 4 tenths off Maldo.

He's had 46 Grands Prix and hasn't really put in an impressive drive.

_________________
Jenson Button & Williams F1 Team supporter!

In 2012 Malaysia? China? Hungary? Abu dhabi?

_________________

Button suffered a lot with tyre temperature this year in qualify, and he is far more experienced than Bruno:

some examples:

Barcellona: Ham 2nd, But 11 th
Monaco: Ham 4th, But 13th
Canada: Ham 2nd, But 10 th
Valencia: Ham 2nd, But 9th
Silverstone: Ham 8th, But 18th
Korea: Ham 3th, But 11th
USA: Ham 2th, But 12 th

Like Maldonado, Hamilton is very aggressive and can get most of the tyres on the flying lap.

people have used testing as a yard stick for bottas

People from Williams that is, not some fans.

And these people from Williams said Bottas is fundamentally the quickest of Maldonado, Senna, Bottas trio, which tells awful lot about how horrible Senna was this year and how badly Williams drivers underperformed due to their driving, be it being slow or crashing or getting penalty every weekend.

_________________
I know what I'm talking about.

Agreed the average fan wouldn't have a clue regarding testing times due to fuel loads etc, but certainly Williams have all the data they need to decide Bottas is the better bet

_________________
PF1 Pick 10 Competition

2013: 5th Place
2014: Champion
2015: 3rd Place
2016: 4th Place
2017: 9th Place
2018: Currently 12th

Wins: Abu Dhabi 2017
Podiums: 2nd Canada 2015, 3rd Monza 2016, Hungary 2016 and Barcelona 2015